Jabril Henley Sr 25, of New Castle was spotted in the Sheetz store on Franklin Street taking a box of Lunchables and a bag of sour cream potato chips.
Police got to the store and saw two security officers chasing the suspect.
He was stopped after trying to get into a vehicle parked nearby. Upon being placed in handcuffs, Henley seemed confused by all the fuss, according to police.
Police said Henley, who also appeared to be intoxicated, admitted he had been drinking that night.